From the Rochester New York Democrat and Chronicle newspaper on August 15, 1982. While there are errors (both parents did not die in World War Two; he was never smuggled to Paris), this Associated Press (AP) posting appeared in newspapers worldwide. It was this very article that started David A. Ferré on his 30-year search into the life and times of André Tchaikowsky.


BBC TV series "QI" features André's skull - Click Here


The "Skull" portion of a BBC Radio 3 Broadcast, "A Study in Contrast" from July 10, 1992, narrated by pianist David Owen Norris, with Terry Harrison and Peter Frankl (courtesy of the BBC): contrast_skull.mp3



(UK) TV broadcast Dec. 2, 2008
channel4_skull_story.mp3

Click Here for a video Link
Voices: Jon Snow, Stephanie West, Terry Harrison, and
Judy Arnold
(Also on YouTube - Click Here)



(USA) National Public Radio
broadcast about the skull
Dec. 3, 2008 npr_skull.mp3

Voice: Renee Montagne
Click Here for NPR Webpage




(USA) Public Broadcasting System (PBS) website for "Great Performances" has David Tennant's "Hamlet" online. Chapter 18 features André's skull. Click Here.



Derek Jacobi "Hamlet" (1979)
with a plastic skull



Roger Rees "Hamlet" (1984)
with a plastic skull



Mark Rylance "Hamlet" (1989)
with a replica of André's skull



David Tennant "Hamlet" (2008)
with André's skull



Shakespeare's violated bodies:
Stage and Screen Performance

by Pascale Aebischer



Skull of André Tchaikowsky
(photo: John Batten Photography)



Edward Bennett "Hamlet" (2008)
With André's skull



Poster outside of Novello
Theatre, London (2008-2009)
[Photo: Cecilia Leung]


Novello Theatre showing RSC's Hamlet (2008-2009)
[Photo: Cecilia Leung]



UPI News Article (2008)
(Reported to be André's skull)



Skull News in English (2008)



Skull News in Polish (2008)



Skull News in German (2008)



Skull News in Hungarian (2008)



Skull News in Italian (2008)



Skull News in Portuguese (2008)



Skull News in Russian (2008)



Skull News in Spanish (2008)



Skull News in Swedish (2008)



Skull News in Turkish (2008)



Skull News in Ukrainian (2008)




From the Telegraph, Nov. 2009




International Piano Magazine
Jan/Feb 2009 Issue



Skull letter from Funeral Directors (1982)



Death Certificate (1982)



Roger Rees Hamlet Poster with André's skull (1984-1985)



Portion of the Will (1979)



Article in Telegraph Daily
See November 2009 Update




Article in Jewish Daily Forward
See December 2009 Update




Production company for Hamlet
DVD featuring André's skull



Hamlet Graveyard Scene
with André's skull (2009)
(BBC television broadcast)



Royal Mail Issue Detail - Hamlet Stamp with André's Skull
(Click Here or Image)


The Hamlet Stamp
(Click Here or Image)


 

André's skull on BBC-TV "QI" (Quite Interesting) Program - May 2012
The BBC television series "Quite Interesting" - or "QI" to its friends - could loosely be described as a comedy panel quiz. Hosted by Stephen Fry, the stellar line-up of comedians is expected to be able to answer any question. The subject for this May 2012 QI edition was... Shakespeare.

Click Here to view the video file (53Mb - allow several minutes to load).

Click Here to learn more about the BBC television series QI.

André Tchaikowsky on UK Royal Mail Postage Stamp - April 2011
From the Royal Mail website: "On 12 April [2011] Royal Mail marks the 50th Anniversary of the Royal Shakespeare Company, with Stamps and a Miniature Sheet. Working with the RSC, Royal Mail selected six RSC productions of Shakespeare’s plays from the last half century for the Stamps and created a Miniature Sheet which comprises four stamps showing the theatres where the RSC has performed in Stratford-upon-Avon through the years." As suggested above, one of these six stamps includes David Tennant (Hamlet) holding the skull of André Tchaikowsky and, thus, André now appears on a UK Royal Mail First Class Postage stamp!

Click Here for the Royal Mail Website about the Hamlet stamp.

Click Here or the image for a larger view of the Hamlet stamp.

Skull "Hamlet" Update - January 2010
From July to November, 2008, the skull used in the graveyard scene in the Stratford Royal Shakespeare Company (RSC) production of Hamlet was that of André Tchaikowsky, but the use of the skull was a secret. When the production moved to London in December, 2008, the secret got out and the RSC announced they would not use the skull for the London run. However, this was not the case and the RSC continued to use André's skull right through to the last performance on January 10, 2009. Thus, André had his time on stage and was returned to a box in the RSC prop room, but for only for a short while because the BBC decided to make a TV dramatisation of the RSC production with David Tennant, and to once again use André's skull.

January, 2010 - The DVD was released of Hamlet featuring the skull of André Tchaikowsky, used in Act 5, Scene 1 (graveyard scene). You can view this scene and scene text using the links below. Be prepared - the opening of Act 5, Scene 1 shows André's skull in close up.

"Skull" Videos on YouTube

Hamlet Act 5, Scene 1 (part 1) Click Here
Hamlet Act 5, Scene 1 (part 2) Click Here
Entire Hamlet Production Click Here
David Tennant on Hamlet (13:40 to 14:43) Click Here
David Tennant on Hamlet (continued) (0:00 to 2:02) Click Here

"Skull" Videos as MP4 Files
Hamlet Act 5, Scene 1 (part 1) Right-Click Here and save the file. Play using Quicktime or Media Player.
Hamlet Act 5, Scene 1 (part 2) Right-Click Here and save the file. Play using Quicktime or Media Player.

The entire Hamlet production is also available online on the Public Broadcasting System (PBS) "Great Performances" website (Click Here), where the graveyard scene is recorded as Chapter 18 on the website. This was broadcast by PBS on April 28, 2010.

Illuminations "Hamlet" on DVD - December 2009
Illuminations is an independent production company and media publisher that specializes in making and distributing films about the arts. It was Illuminations that filmed David Tennant as Hamlet for BBC2 television for broadcast on December 26, 2009. As in the stage production in both Stratford (2008) and London (2008-2009), the skull of André Tchaikowsky was used in the graveyard scene for the BBC2 broadcast. This Hamlet production is available for purchase as a Digital Video Disc (DVD) and is in the European PAL television format. Click Here for purchasing information from Illuminations.

BBC News about the skull
A good summary of the skull, it's history and how it came about (Click Here).

Story of the Skull - From the Biography
The following text is from the book, The Other Tchaikowsky - A Biographical Sketch of André Tchaikowsky, and describes what is known about the André's donation of his skull to be used in Shakespeare theatrical productions of Hamlet.


The Skull Bequest
After André's death, Terry and Eve Harrison went to André's home to advise his neighbors of the unhappy news. They found a will, written on October 10, 1979. It seemed a standard document, except for the end of Clause 13:

13. I HEREBY REQUEST that my body or any part thereof may be used for therapeutic purposes including corneal grafting and organ transplantation or for the purposes of medical education or research in accordance with the provisions of the Human Tissue Act 1961 and in due course the institution receiving it shall have my body cremated with the exception of my skull, which shall be offered by the institution receiving my body to the Royal Shakespeare Company for use in theatrical performance.

The bequest of André's skull to the Royal Shakespeare Company was a surprise, but Terry and Eve were determined that André's last wishes be honored. Terry telephoned playwright Christopher Hampton ("Les Liaisons Dangereuses"). Hampton lived in Oxford and they had become friendly when André decided to undertake an opera based on Hampton's play, "Total Eclipse." Hampton called a friend at the RSC, joint artistic director Terry Hands. Terry Hands:

"I was informed of the bequest immediately after André's death and asked Christopher Hampton how seriously felt was the request. It did seem serious. André was passionate about Shakespeare and had attended many performances at the RSC. We were honoured and we accepted. It was agreed that when next we played Hamlet, it would be used."

The funeral directors at Reeves and Pain who were handling the cremation refused to remove André's head, and further, they believed such a bequest was illegal. Terry contacted his legal advisors who in turn contacted the British Home Office. The Home Office decided the bequest was not illegal and the RSC could accept the gift. Reeves and Pain asked that the head be removed by a medical staff member at the hospital before they picked up the body. This was done. At virtually the last minute, Reeves and Pain was able to obtain André's remains from the hospital, sans cranium, in time to prepare his ashes for the memorial service on July 2. The head was turned over to a museum for processing.

The memorial service for André Tchaikowsky was announced in a letter from Terry Harrison:

André Tchaikowsky will be cremated at the Oxford Crematorium, Bayswater Road, Oxford, at 11 a.m. on Friday, July 2. We are following André's wish that the service not be religious. The cremation will be conducted by Chad Varah, the founder of The Samaritans and a very close friend of André's. At the beginning of the ceremony we shall have a performance of André's Trio Notturno which will receive its world premiere at the Cheltenham Festival on the evening of July 4. It was recorded for André by the trio he wrote it for Peter Frankl, Gyorgy Pauk, and Ralph Kirshbaum -- three days before he died, and it was the last piece of music he heard. At the end of the ceremony we shall playa recording of the adagio from Schubert's Quintet in C major for Strings, Opus 163, which André particularly loved.

The genesis of the skull bequest comes from a conversation between André and his manager, Terry Harrison. André suggested to Terry that he would leave his skull to the Royal Shakespeare Company so that they might have a real skull for Hamlet productions. As Pascale Aebischer relates in her book, Shakespeare's Violated Bodies, André's skull might not be used in Hamlet because the actors always saw André instead of Yorick:

The extend of the skull’s capacity for extrafictional reference and its concomitant potential to substantially influence the interpretation of the scene first became apparent to me when I began my research on Ron Daniels’s second RSC production [in 1989]. In the middle of a stack of archival material about the production, I found a memorandum, dated 9 May 1989, that read: “If André Tchaikovsky isn’t actually playing Yorick this year, please can we have his skull back in the Collection for future reference, or whatever you do with skulls of dead pianists.” The story I managed to piece together from this point of departure is the following.

In 1980, André Tchaikovsky, an Oxford-based classical musician, saw Michael Pennington’s performance of the role of Hamlet in Stratford-upon-Avon. He was so taken by the macabre dialogue in the graveyard scene that on his way home to told his companion [Terry Harrison] of his intention to bequeath his skull to the RSC so that he - or at least a part of him - might appear as Yorick in a future production of Hamlet. A few years later, the property department manager for the RSC, William Lockwood, received a call from an undertaker [M. J. Duckworth for Reeves & Pain, Funeral Directors, Oxford] who asked whether the RSC might be interested in the cranium of a deceased client. Horrified, Mr. Lockwood passed the question on to Terry Hands (at the time the RSCs artistic director), who promptly accepted the bequest. A mere ten days later, to Lockwood’s discomfiture and evident delight of the department’s dog, Mr. Lockwood received a cardboard parcel containing the freshly processed golden-toothed skull of André Tchaikovsky. After extensive airing [two years on the roof of an RSC building], if found a provisional resting place on a shelf in the property department.

He briefly left the shelf for a photo-session with Roger Rees for the poster of Daniels’s 1984 production, but was immediately sent back to rest, a Fiberglas cast of his cranium taking his place in the theatre. André Tchaikovsky’s first genuine chance to star as Yorick came only in 1989, when Mark Rylance started to rehearse the title role of Hamlet in Daniels’s production. A rehearsal note dated 13 February 1989 records: “Mark Rylance has asked whether it would be possible to use the real skull that was donated to the RSC as Yorick’s skull?” The property department complied, and Tchaikovsky appears to have spent one month in the rehearsal room preparing the role of Yorick.

On 23 March 1989, however, the first indication of trouble is casually mentioned in a rehearsal note: “we will be using the real skull for Yorick but will need a standby in case of accident.” What accident? Although Tchaikovsky must have been aware that playing Yorick would entail being “knocked about the mazard with a sexton’s spade” (5.1.85-6), Rylance’s desire to grant Tchaikovsky’s wish seems thus to have been paradoxically checked by a simultaneous desire to honour the dead. Eventually, squeamishness about the rough handling of real human remains seems to have triumphed. Claire van Kampen, the production’s musical director and later Mark Rylance’s wife, remembers that:

“As a company, we all felt most privileged to be able to work the gravedigger scene with a real skull... However, collectively as a group we agreed that as the real power of theatre lies in the complicity of illusion between actor and audience, it would be inappropriate to use a real skull during the performances, in the same way that we would not be using real blood, etc. It is possible that some of us felt a certain primitive taboo about the skull, although the gravedigger, as I recall, was all for it!”

On 7 April 1989, a last rehearsal note records how Tchaikovsky was finally defeated in his quest for on-stage remembrance, although touchingly, the understudy to replace him was to be an exact look-alike: “We are no longer using the real skull as Yorick but would like to use a cast of it (complete with teeth).”

In spite of his early retirement to the shelf in the property department, Tchaikovsky’s presence in the rehearsal room left a deep mark on the production’s interpretation of the tragedy’s concluding moments. The graveyard scene opened with the gravedigger (played by Jimmy Gardner, the actor implicitly accused by van Dampen of having an inappropriate attitude towards Tchaikovsky’s remains) using the skull as a pawn with which to illustrate the legal intricacies of Ophelia’s inquest, Rylance’s accusatory tone when his Hamlet commented that, “That skull had a tongue in it, and could sing once” (5.1.74), while ostensibly referring to the (at that point anonymous) fictional owner of the skull within the world of the play, was charged with an additional, reproachful meaning in its reference to the two actors’ disagreement over the proper treatment of Tchaikovsky’s head.

When quizzing the gravedigger about the decomposition of bodies, Hamlet jumped into the grave to get a closer look at it all. It was thus in the grave that was shortly to be Ophelia’s that he was handed Yorick’s skull atop the Gravedigger’s spade, when as eleven years later in Lester’s hands, it became a puppet that was mused over by a wistful Hamlet who strained to hear Yorick’s silent answers to his question, making the skull come back to life as his chopfallen interlocutor. The aimless existential despair of Rylance’s Hamlet was here converted into focused, intense mourning and tenderness for the skull. Yorick seemed to have taken over the roles of the Ghost and Polonius as the old mole/perturbed spirit/foolish prating knave in the grave hovering on the brink between life and death, remembrance and oblivion.

Hamlet’s composure in his confrontation with Laertes in the graveyard seemed to spring out of this encounter with death and memory in the shape of Yorick, whom he lovingly carried into the next scene, his cradling of the cranium mirroring Laertes’s mournful rocking of Ophelia’s body in the grave. Yorick was casually tucked under Hamlet’s arm during his dialogue with Osric, deposited on the floor for Hamlet’s handshake with Laertes and finally carefully set down on a mantelpiece, where Hamlet “turn[ed] it so that its eyeless sockets faced the action, as a talisman during his duel with Laertes.” How closely this performance choice was linked to Tchaikovsky’s presence in the rehearsal room is clear from van Kampen’s comment that “Probably it was this very realness [of the skull] that fired Mark [Rylance]’s imagination to believe that the power of Hamlet’s father’s old jester was so great that, as a kind of talisman, or fetish, Hamlet takes him through Act V to his, Hamlet’s own death.”

The skull of Tchaikovsky and/or Yorick thus had the effect of doubling Hamlet’s quest for revenge and confrontation with death with Mark Rylance’s desire to honour the last will of Tchaikovsky, who became the company’s own uncomfortable memento mori and its Ghost clamouring for posthumous remembrance. Because the property disturbingly kept its extrafictional and extratheatrical identity as the property (in the sense of ownership) of André Tchaikovsky the pianist, it resisted the company’s attempted to appropriate it as an accessory. Instead, it became an “improper property” that defied theatrical decorum.

In a company such as the RSC that generally uses non-Grotowskian techniques, decorum dictates that theatrical signs which pertain to the human body (by they objects such as bones or blood or physical expression such as pain or orgasm) should stay at a distance from their referent, a distance which, as Claire van Kampen put it, is bridged by “the complicity of illusion between actor and audience.” Only when the real skull, with its real identity as André Tchaikovsky’s head, was replaced by an identical-looking fake was the company able to adopt the property as an iconic sign that could stand primarily for Yorick rather than Tchaikovsky.

Aebischer's guess that it was the 1980 RSC Hamlet production that stirred André skull bequest could not be correct because the Will was signed in October, 1979. A better guess would be the 1979 production at the Old Vic Theatre in London, with Derek Jacobi as Hamlet.

Typical of the André Tchaikowsky obituary notices is one by Alan Blyth of The Daily Telegraph, which appeared on June 30. (All of the obituary notices contained errors, the most common of which were that both of his parents were killed during the war and that he was smuggled out of Poland to Paris.)

André Tchaikowsky, pianist and composer, died on the weekend in Oxford. He was 46, and although ill since the beginning of the year, he recovered sufficiently to resume playing in May. He also managed to complete an opera based on "The Merchant of Venice."

He was born in Warsaw on November 1, 1935. Both his parents were killed under the Nazi occupation, but he was smuggled out to Paris. After the War he studied there and also in his homeland before winning the coveted Chopin Prize in the Polish capital in 1955, completing his studies with the Polish pianist, Stefan Askenase. His British debut was in 1958. He decided to make his home in Britain while continuing to build an international career as a pianist with a wide-ranging repertory. His particular loves were Bach and Mozart.

Over the past 20 years, he devoted about half his time to composing. His list of works included the Piano Concerto written for Radu Lupu and given its first performance by him 10 years ago. Apart from his opera, Tchaikowsky had also completed a Trio Notturno for piano trio. It will be given its premiere at the Cheltenham Festival on Monday.

His playing tended to be ebullient and full of an instinctive feeling for the style of the composer. He was an inveterate follower of his fellow pianists and until his last illness could be seen at practically every recital of note in London.

In Germany, a Frankfurt newspaper reported:

Composer and Pianist -- The Death of André Tchaikowsky

The well-known and highly regarded pianist André Tchaikowsky died from cancer on June 26 at the age of 46, near his home in Oxford. He was one of the most talented pianists of his generation, and a Mozart player of the first rank, with individual and subjective interpretations in comparison to the "classic" interpretations. Tchaikowsky gave to his performances a rare feeling of color and contour. His Chopin playing was witty, often with strong rubato and changes in tempi -- sometimes a bit over the top -- but always revealing the structure of the composition. To summarize, André Tchaikowsky thought musically first, and pianistically second.

In Poland, André's passing was memorialized with a series of seven radio programs of two hours each. The programs, organized by Jan Weber of Polish Radio, included André as pianist, and André as composer, interspersed with interviews of his friends, in particular, with Halina Wahlmann-Janowska, who read portions of the letters she had received over the many years of their correspondence. Although André never returned to Poland after 1956, he remained well-known there, and interest in both his piano playing and composing has remained high.

The museum entrusted with André's skull returned it, processed, to Reeves and Pain on July 18. Reeves and Pain then reported to Terry Harrison on July 22, "André's skull was delivered to the Royal Shakespeare Company at Stratford-Upon-Avon on Tuesday, 20th July." Up to this point, the bequest had remained private. Mr. Duckworth, funeral director at Reeves and Pain, was interested in publishing the story of André's skull in a funeral directors' professional magazine and asked Terry Harrison for his opinion. Terry responded on August 4:

Eve and I have no objections to your reporting the bequest of André's skull in your professional magazine. However, could you let me know whether you would particularly want to use his name, or were you thinking the deceased would be nameless? My present thought is that we would not mind his name being used, but I would just like to think about that point a little more.

Terry wasn't permitted the luxury of further thinking. Someone informed the press about the strange bequest and the story hit, first, the London papers, then the international news services, in particular the Associated Press. The news of André's skull quickly spread worldwide, from the US to Australia and beyond. Mr. Duckworth wrote an immediate letter to Terry Harrison assuring him that Reeves and Pain was not responsible for the news leak. Terry responded on August 24:

I was away for two weeks so missed the news escaping about André's skull. My secretary Claire heard the broadcast of this news item on Independent Radio and she told me she didn't think it was offensive. I would have preferred that the news had not come out, but quite honestly I don't think it is particularly bad that people know, as André was rather an extraordinary person and it would have touched his sense of whimsy to know that he caused some consternation. So don't worry about the matter. I presume it must have been leaked by somebody connected with the hospital.

A sampling of the newspaper articles suggests the stir caused by André’s final eccentricity. From The Times in London on August 14:

Pianist’s Skull Waits in Wings

Mr. André Tchaikowsky , the Polish-born concert pianist, asked in his will that his skull be given to the Royal Shakespeare Company for use in future productions of Hamlet. Mr. Michael Duckworth, a partner in Reeves and Pain, an Oxford firm of undertakers, said Mr. Tchaikowsky, who died at his home near Oxford in June, apparently had a lifelong ambition to be an actor. The RSC said the skull had been delivered and would be stored. The company does not have plans to stage "Hamlet" in the immediate future.

From The Daily Telegraph in London on August 14 by Anthony Hopkins:

Hamlet Gets a Skull in Bequest

"This same skull, sir, was Yorick's skull, the King's jester." "Alas, poor Yorick. I knew him, Horatio: a fellow of infinite jest." -- Hamlet

A man who nursed a lifelong ambition to go on the stage has bequeathed his skull to the Royal Shakespeare Company for use in productions of "Hamlet." Mr. André Tchaikowsky, a concert pianist and composer, died at his home at Cumnor, near Oxford, in June, aged 46. Now his skull has been delivered in a box to the RSC. A spokesman for Mr. Terry Hands, the RSC's joint artistic director, said that Mr. Tchaikowsky had been an avid Shakespeare enthusiast with a love of the stage. "We were staggered when the executors of the Will asked if we wanted the skull."

Mr. Michael Duckworth, a partner in the undertaking firm of Reeves and Pain, said: "Mr. Tchaikowsky's friends and executors desperately wanted to fulfill his wishes and we are here to do what we can for our clients."

The RSC has no immediate plans for a production of "Hamlet." "But when we stage it again we hope to use Mr. Tchaikowsky's skull," said a spokesman. Meanwhile, the skull, still in its box, is in store at the RSC's headquarters in Stratford-upon-Avon.

In 1984, the Royal Shakespeare Company did produce "Hamlet." Actor Roger Rees (Hamlet) remembers the situation:

''I'm afraid André's skull was not used directly on stage for the actual production of 'Hamlet.' We found long ago that a real head is too fragile to be used in the rather rough-handling gravedigger scene, so we use plastic skulls which hold up better. However, the RSC was delighted to have a real skull for their various needs. When they first got the skull, they put it outdoors for a few months, in the sunlight, to dry it out completely and to bleach it bone white.

"The skull was used as part of the 'Hamlet' poster for the 1984 production in Stratford and the 1985 production in London. I had to pose for this poster, two hours a day, for three days running. In my hands, I hold a skull, and that's André's skull. The artist was Phillip Core and he remarked that it must be a real skull because it still had bits of gristle around the ear ports, and various places. So indirectly, André's skull was used for Hamlet."

André, of course, had never wanted to be an actor on the stage. He was, instead, a great enthusiast of theater and loved the works of Shakespeare. But what was the real reason for the bequest? When his friends heard about the skull, no one seemed surprised. "Typical André," was the comment most often heard. Michael Menaugh remembers:

"Unfortunately, the fact of the skull will not go away for any of us. It is something that ultimately we have all to come to terms with, to reconcile with the André we knew and loved. I don't think André realized the effect such a bequest would have, both on his friends and on his own reputation. André didn't always understand that the world of ideas and the world of real people, real reactions and real events just did not coincide.

"He had spoken to me of leaving his skull for the RSC to use in Hamlet back in 1966 when he wrote the music for my Oxford Hamlet. In my undergraduate way, I thought the idea wonderfully entertaining. When a great actor may hold the skull of a real man, a real man who 'set the table on a roar,' a wonderful man who had his 'gibes and gambols and songs,' when that great actor says, 'A fellow of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy,' might not that electrifying flash of truth (transmitted by the actor) light up the play? André would have liked that idea, I think."

November 2008 to January 2009 Update
After more than 25 years in the wings, André's wish to appear in Shakespeare's play Hamlet as the skull of Yorick was realized at last. The Royal Shakespeare Company (RSC) 2008 production of Hamlet used André's skull from July to November in Stratford, but then declined to use it when the production moved to London in December, 2008, because the secret use of the skull had been revealed. From the Telegraph newspaper (London), November 22, 2008, an (abridged) article by Vicki Reid:

David Tennant: from Doctor Who to Hamlet

There is one intriguing story about the production that among all the mayhem has managed to remain untold. During the run, the company has played each performance with an extra member. On the first day of rehearsals the cast was introduced to a real skull - that of André Tchaikowsky, a Polish composer who settled in Oxford, where he continued to compose and visited Stratford often.

He died of cancer in 1982 at the age of 46, and bequeathed his skull to the RSC, where it sat in a box in the props department, before Doran decided he was going to use it. He hoped it might bring the cast closer to the text: 'This play has to touch something in us - we have to face our own mortality, and Hamlet has to face that. It was sort of a little shock tactic, though, of course, to some extent that wears off and it's just André, in his box.'

Doran didn't want the story to get out before Hamlet opened. 'I thought it would topple the play and it would be all about David acting with a real skull. 'Tennant was delighted to be fulfilling Tchaikowsky's wishes. 'When I heard he had done this,' he says, 'I thought, that's brilliant, that's what I'm going to do, but apparently you can't any more, the law's been changed.'

David Smith wrote for the Guardian and The Observer on Nov. 23, 2008:

Pianist's skull plays the jester

'Alas, poor Yorick,' laments Hamlet, holding up the skull of the King's late jester. The gravedigger scene in the hit production of Hamlet starring David Tennant can claim unprecedented realism. For each night Tennant is holding aloft a genuine skull.

The extra cast member is André Tchaikowsky, a Polish concert pianist and composer who, after his death from cancer in 1982, bequeathed his skull to the Royal Shakespeare Company in the hope of achieving his acting dream. The skull sat in a box in the props department, virtually untouched for 25 years, until director Gregory Doran retrieved it for its stage debut.

Tchaikowsky's posthumous performance, which it is safe to assume makes up in consistency what it lacks in expressiveness, was kept secret when the show opened in Stratford-upon-Avon, where there was already massive hype around Doctor Who star Tennant.

Tchaikowsky emigrated from Poland to Oxford in 1939, when he was four, and was a frequent visitor to Stratford. He died at the age of 46 and left a will requesting that his organs be used for medical purposes, 'with the exception of my skull, which shall be offered by the institution receiving my body to the Royal Shakespeare Company for use in theatrical performance'.

The Home Office decided the bequest was not illegal and the RSC could accept the gift. The company put the skull outdoors for a few months so the sunlight would dry it out completely. Actor Mark Rylance spent a month rehearsing with the skull when he played Hamlet in 1989, but 'eventually, squeamishness about the rough handling of real human remains seems to have triumphed.'

Seventeen years later, however, Doran decided to take the plunge. 'It was sort of a little shock tactic... though, of course, to some extent that wears off and it's just André, in his box,' he said.

Debbie Waite wrote for the Oxford Mail on Nov. 26, 2008:

Skull gets starring role

An Oxford man has achieved his dying wish to have his skull used in Hamlet — 26 years after he donated it to the Royal Shakespeare Company. Concert pianist André Tchaikowsky’s skull lay unused in a box, because actors shied away from performing with it on stage. But now it has been revealed Dr. Who actor David Tennant held the skull aloft during the famous 'Alas, poor Yorick' scene in a 22-show run at the theatre in Stratford-upon-Avon.

Mr. Tchaikowsky, a Holocaust survivor who came to Oxford after the Second World War, made it a condition of his will to give the body part away in the hope it would be used in a theatrical performance. Despite being used in rehearsals, the skull had never been in a stage performance until Hamlet director Greg Doran retrieved it from its protective box in the RSC’s climate-controlled archives.

The play moves to London next week but it is yet to be decided if Mr. Tennant will use the skull there. Mr. Tchaikowsky’s family were delighted his skull had at long last been used on stage. Mr. Tchaikowsky, who lived in Cumnor, regularly attended performances in Stratford before his death from cancer at the age of 46. David Howells, curator of the archives, said:

“It has never been used on stage before. In 1989 the actor Mark Rylance rehearsed with it for quite a while but he couldn’t get past the fact it wasn’t Yorick’s, it was André Tchaikowsky’s. That, and the fear of an accident and it being slightly macabre, was why they decided not to use it and used an exact replica.”

The RSC had to apply for special permission to use the skull from the Human Tissue Authority, as it is less than 100 years old. Mr. Doran, who made the decision to use it, explained why he didn’t want anyone to know. He said:

“I thought it would topple the play and it would be all about David acting with a real skull. It was sort of a little shock tactic, though, of course, to some extent that wore off and it was just André, in his box.”

In Hamlet, a gravedigger unearths the skull of jester Yorick, prompting Hamlet to deliver the line: “Alas, poor Yorick! I knew him, Horatio: a fellow of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy.” Dave Ferre, a friend of the Tchaikowsky family, said: “That was André’s dream and this is great news. The family will be pleased.”

Richard Faulks, the current manager of the Reeves and Pain Funeral Directors in Oxford, which dealt with Mr. Tchaikowsky’s request, was surprised to hear about the intriguing tale. He said:

“Unfortunately the funeral director Michael Duckworth is no longer with us, but I have been back through our records and we still have the forms relating to Mr. Tchaikowsky. It has been very interesting reading about him – he sounds like quite a personality. We’re delighted to learn that his dying wishes have at last been realised.”

From the Associated Press by writer Robert Barr:

Human skull used in British Hamlet production

LONDON (AP) - A Polish pianist has made his stage debut in Britain, 26 years after his death. André Tchaikowsky's skull featured in performances of "Hamlet" by the Royal Shakespeare Company between July and November [2008], company spokeswoman Nada Zakula said Wednesday. It was the first time the skull was used in a performance - his expressed wish - though the company had used in rehearsals since it was donated in 1982.

Tchaikowsky's 1979 will had asked that his skull be offered to the Royal Shakespeare Company "for use in theatrical performance." "We hope that he would have been pleased that his final wish has been realized," company curator David Howells said. It was unclear if the skull would be used when the company's production moves from its base in Stratford-upon-Avon to London on Dec. 3, Zakula said.

Tchaikowsky, a fan of William Shakespeare's plays, had finished orchestrating all but 24 bars of his operatic adaptation of "The Merchant of Venice" when he died from stomach cancer on June 26, 1982. News of his unique bequest became known soon after. "He was passionate about Shakespeare and attended many performances," Terry Hands told the AP in 1982 when he was joint artistic director of the company. "We are honored by his bequest."

Andrzej Czajkowski was born in 1935 in the Polish capital of Warsaw as Robert Andrzej Krauthammer, but was given his new name on false identity documents used to smuggle him out of Nazi-occupied Warsaw in 1942, according to a Web site dedicated to the musician.

December 2008 Update
Once the RSC had made the decision to not use the skull in the London Hamlet production, other news articles appeared. [Note that the RSC actually continued to use André's skull.] Typical is that from this December 3rd, 2008 article posted on Yahoo News:

Skull dropped after secret revealed

A human skull will no longer be used in the Royal Shakespeare Company's (RSC's) Hamlet in case it distracts the audience, the theatre company said. The skull of Polish pianist André Tchaikowsky was used throughout the play's recent run in Stratford-upon-Avon, but the unusual prop will be dropped when it opens in London's West End, the RSC said.

Audiences in Stratford were unaware the skull in the play belonged to the pianist, who had bequeathed it to the RSC in 1982 for this purpose, a spokeswoman said. But the secret spilled out when actor David Tennant, who plays Hamlet, revealed it in a newspaper interview.

The RSC told Channel 4 News that now the secret is out, it would be "too distracting for the audience" if the skull was used.

Substituting the real skull for a fake one will also stop the RSC having to gain permission from the Human Tissue Authority, which it needed before using the real one in Stratford, the spokeswoman added.

"We never planned to use the real one in the London run," she said.

In the Stratford production, Tennant held the skull aloft in the "Alas poor Yorick" scene of the play, fulfilling the dying wish of Mr. Tchaikowsky - a Polish Jew who escaped the Holocaust but died of cancer aged 46.

His former agent and friend Terry Harrison told Channel 4 News he was "disappointed" by the decision to abandon the real skull.

The Telegraph reports David Tennant out until at least Christmas and undergoes surgery for a back problem. He is replaced by Edward Bennett for all of December. However, on January 4th, 2009, Tennant returns for the last 6 days of performances to superlative reviews.

November 2009 Update
From the Telegraph of November 24, 2009:

David Tennant to revive partnership
with real skull for BBC's Hamlet

David Tennant is to revive his partnership with a real human skull for a new BBC film version of Shakespeare's Hamlet. The skull had starred in a stage run of the classic production last year after pianist Andre Tchaikowsky left his remains to the Royal Shakespeare Company in the hope it would be used on stage. Now it is being used in a TV dramatisation of the RSC production to be screened this Christmas.

The boss of the RSC admitted that the company secretly used the skull during the play's London run, despite the company saying at the time it was to use a fake. Tennant held the skull on stage during the famed ''Alas, poor Yorick'' scene for more than 20 performances at the Courtyard Theatre, in Stratford-upon-Avon. The outgoing Doctor Who star was lauded for his performance in the production and it has now been filmed for BBC2.

Greg Doran, who directed the stage and TV versions said: ''Yes, Andre appears in the film - as in fact he did throughout both the Stratford and the London runs.'' He explained: ''I didn't allow news that he transferred to London to be leaked out, as we did not want audiences to be unnecessarily distracted by what had then become a bit of a news story.

''Andre Tchaikowsky's skull was a very important part of our production of Hamlet, and despite all the hype about him, he meant a great deal to the company.

''Yorick's skull, and Hamlet's lament to him, is probably one of the most famous icons in Shakespeare, and one most frequently satirised and misquoted. It was through Andre that the company tried to get beyond those clichés, to investigate something deeper.

''You can't hold a real human skull in your hand and not be moved by the realisation that your own skull sits just beneath your skin, that you will be reduced to that state at some stage. That is what Yorick's skull does to Hamlet. It reminds him of the very real presence of Death in Life. Andre's skull was a profound momento mori, which perhaps no prop skull could quite provide.''

Composer and concert pianist Tchaikowsky died of cancer in 1982 at the age of 46, donating his body for medical science. But he also requested that his skull be offered to the RSC to be used on stage. Although it had been used in rehearsals, actors did not feel comfortable using his head in front of an audience.
Mark Rylance used a cast of Tchaikowsky's skull 20 years ago after initially practising his performance with the real thing. The musician's remains then went back to a box until the skull was used by Tennant. It had to be given a special license for use and a stand-in had to be used until permission was given.

Doran said: ''When the Human Tissues Authority (HTA) license had not arrived by the evening of the Dress rehearsal in Stratford last July, and we had to place Andre back in his box, our Theatre Collections Curator, David Howells, allowed us to use another skull he had in the collection, which as it was more than 100 years old, did not come under the jurisdiction of the HTA.

''It was the skull used as Yorick by Edmund Kean in 1813. A piece of theatre history happened that night on the Stratford stage as David Tennant, a 21st century Hamlet, stared into the empty eye sockets that a nineteenth century Hamlet had used. For those of us watching, a little shiver of connection occurred.''

Doran, who is also chief associate director of the RSC, added: ''I suspect Andre would have been amused by the fact that his cranium became a question on Have I got News for You?, but his bequest to the RSC was deeply sincere. 'I hope other productions may, with the greatest respect for Andre, use the skull as he intended it to be used, for precisely this purpose.''

December 2009 Update
From the Jewish Daily Forward of December 8, 2009 by Benjamin Ivry:

'Alas, Poor Andrzej': The Strange Case
of Tchaikowsky's Skull

The admission by London’s Royal Shakespeare Company that, despite previous disavowals, a production of “Hamlet” featured not only Dr Who actor David Tennant, but also a real human skull onstage — as Hamlet’s deceased friend the jester Yorick — brings the donor of that skull back into the limelight.

The Polish-Jewish pianist Andrzej Czajkowski (who performed as André Tchaikowsky), born Robert Andrzej Krauthammer in 1935 bequeathed his skull to the Royal Shakespeare Company to be used as Yorick after he died prematurely of colon cancer at age 46. Until the most recent “Hamlet,” no production had the kishkas to do so, and even now, the theatre (deceptively, as it turned out) claimed to withdraw the skull after it proved a “distraction” to audiences, supposedly replacing it with a plastic replica.

In fact, Czajkowski’s skull was used all along, including in a soon-to-be-seen BBC filmed version of the play. Czajkowski, a Warsaw Ghetto survivor and greatly talented performer and composer (whose few recordings are all available for online listening at the tribute site andretchaikowsky.com) thus has a weird posthumous triumph, which ranks him as a pianist comparably gifted to, but even more eccentric than, Glenn Gould.

Czajkowski’s spirited, mysterious recordings of Mozart; dazzling Chopin; witty Haydn; and warm-hearted Schubert won many admirers, including Arthur Rubinstein, an early mentor. Yet most were ultimately turned off by his oddball behavior, which included erratic attendance at scheduled performances and recording sessions, and when he did show up he would pull stunts like at one concert, improvising an endlessly percussive, out-of-style Bartok-like cadenza to a Mozart concerto until the unnamed conductor shouted “Enough!” and made the orchestra play loudly to cut him off.

When challenged about such off-putting deeds, Czajkowski would refer to the difficulty of his childhood, when he was smuggled out of the Ghetto. By the end of his life, too, the social repressiveness of Thatcherism in the UK must also have irked Czajkowski, who led a flamboyantly gay life. An intermittently gifted composer, Czajkowski’s best works, like his “Trio Notturno” allowed him to express some of the darker inner aspects.

Apart from his genuine devotion to Shakespeare and particularly “Hamlet,” Czajkowski’s macabre donation may be seen in the optic of this darkness, a sort of desperate theatricality visible in other Polish creators like the author Tadeusz Borowski, an Auschwitz survivor. Fortunately, Czajkowski’s artistry has survived magnificently, and he will be remembered for what went on in his head not just because of his polished up headbone on stage.